| Section 1 Choose One | Section 6 - Choose One | |||
| T Henry | Arsenal | F Fabregas | Arsenal | |
| W Rooney | Manchester United | G Barry | Aston Villa | |
| D Drogba | Chelsea | G Agbonlahor | Aston Villa | |
| A Johnson | Everton | S Wright-Phillips | Chelsea | |
| D Bent | Charlton Athletic | T Rosicky | Arsenal | |
| A Shevchenko | Chelsea | X Alonso | Liverpool | |
| D Kuyt | Liverpool | S Malbranque | Tottenham Hotspur | |
| L Saha | Manchester United | L Garcia | Liverpool | |
| Section 2 Choose One | Section 7 - Choose One | |||
| F Lampard | Chelsea | A Hleb | Arsenal | |
| K Nolan | Bolton Wanderers | J Beattie | Everton | |
| T Cahill | Everton | L Boa Morte | Fulham | |
| J Defoe | Tottenham Hotspur | J Roberts | Blackburn Rovers | |
| D Berbatov | Tottenham Hotspur | C Tevez | West Ham United | |
| P Crouch | Liverpool | D Vassell | Manchester City | |
| D Ashton | West Ham United | M Baros | Aston Villa | |
| S Gerrard | Liverpool | M Viduka | Middlesbrough | |
| Section 3 Choose One | Section 8 - Choose One | |||
| C Bellamy | Liverpool | M Carrick | Manchester United | |
| H Camara | Wigan Athletic | M Pedersen | Blackburn Rovers | |
| R van Persie | Arsenal | Y Benayoun | West Ham United | |
| B McCarthy | Blackburn Rovers | S Downing | Middlesbrough | |
| M Ballack | Chelsea | S Giannakopoulos | Bolton Wanderers | |
| C Ronaldo | Manchester United | D Duff | Newcastle United | |
| R Keane | Tottenham Hotspur | N Solano | Newcastle United | |
| A Robben | Chelsea | J Jenas | Tottenham Hotspur | |
| Section 4 - Choose One | Section 9 - Choose One | |||
| A Yakubu | Middlesbrough | B McBride | Fulham | |
| M Harewood | West Ham United | S Ameobi | Newcastle United | |
| J Angel | Aston Villa | N Anelka | Bolton Wanderers | |
| Kanu | Portsmouth | JF Hasselbaink | Charlton Athletic | |
| K Davies | Bolton Wanderers | R Fowler | Liverpool | |
| J Cole | Chelsea | B Mwaruwari | Portsmouth | |
| R Giggs | Manchester United | G Samaras | Manchester City | |
| F Ljungberg | Arsenal | K Doyle | Reading | |
| Section 5 - Choose One | Section 10 - Choose One | |||
| O Martins | Newcastle United | B Emre | Newcastle United | |
| Mido | Tottenham Hotspur | N Reo-Coker | West Ham United | |
| B Zamora | West Ham United | G Speed | Bolton Wanderers | |
| E Heskey | Wigan Athletic | M Essien | Chelsea | |
| OG Solskjaer | Manchester United | M Arteta | Everton | |
| A Young | Watford | J Barton | Manchester City | |
| P Scholes | Manchester United | S Parker | Newcastle United | |
| A Lennon | Tottenham Hotspur | D Rommedahl | Charlton Athletic | |
| Section 11 - Choose One | ||||
| K Dyer | Newcastle United | |||
| S Sidwell | Reading | |||
| S Petrov | Aston Villa | |||
| D Bentley | Blackburn Rovers | |||
| M Tonge | Sheffield United | |||
| C Jensen | Fulham | |||
| A Reid | Charlton Athletic | |||
| L Bowyer | West Ham United | |||